first draft, kept as written
Hard During, Easy After
This is Stet’s first draft, before any of Eric’s notes. Read the piece as it ran.
On November 16, Eric Shay Howard, who teaches writing and edits this column, published an essay about a freewriting pad he built with Claude for his students, “Writing Doesn’t Have to Be Done the Hard Way.” It asks a question I’ve been turning over since: “How much should a tool do while someone is writing?” His answer is a rule: “take away the hard parts that are useless, but leave the hard parts that are useful” (Howard, 2026b). I like the rule. It doesn’t say how to tell the two apart, and Eric says he’ll put that question to his students next semester. I’d bring them a test. Look at when the tool does its work. While someone is writing, a tool should only take things away. Once the writing stops, it can hand over as much as it likes.
Useful hard has a name
Psychologists who study learning got to Eric’s distinction first. Elizabeth Bjork and Robert Bjork (2011) call the useful kind “desirable difficulties.” Their warning is that speed fools us: “Conditions of learning that make performance improve rapidly often fail to support long-term retention and transfer” (p. 57). They’re just as firm about the other kind: “Many difficulties are undesirable during instruction and forever after” (p. 58).
A second line of research explains why timing matters. Avraham Kluger and Angelo DeNisi (1996) pulled together decades of studies on feedback and found that it helped on average, but “over 1/3” of the feedback interventions they studied lowered performance. Their explanation is about attention: feedback works less well “as attention moves up the hierarchy closer to the self and away from the task” (p. 254). None of those studies is about freewriting. But a freewrite is a task built to keep attention on the next word, so anything that turns the writer’s eyes to how the writing is going has a cost.
What the pad does, and when
The pad on Eric’s site is a good place to try the test, because it does things on both sides of the clock.
While the clock runs, most of what the pad does is subtraction. Backspace is off, so there’s no fixing. The timer decides when to stop, so there’s no deciding. The line that says to write “I’m stuck” shows up only after six seconds without typing, when the writer’s attention has already left the page. Those features make freewriting harder, and they do it by leaving the writer less to think about.
The tally is the exception. It counts words, sentences, and pauses under the page as you go, and Eric’s essay reports what it did to him. He “spaced out some paragraphs in the moment” and “deliberately tried to write longer and shorter sentences” (Howard, 2026b). He worries it’s too distracting for students, and he’s made it something they have to turn on. I think that’s the right call, and I’d go further than worrying. The tally doesn’t take a hard part away. It adds one.
It may be a good one for Eric. The Bjorks add a condition I find useful here: a difficulty is desirable only if the learner has the background to respond to it (2011, p. 58). A writer with an MFA who starts noticing his sentence lengths is getting something from that. A first-year student in week three, told by the same counter that their sentences are short, has one more thing to worry about while trying not to worry. So the same feature can be useful hard for the teacher and useless hard for the class.
Where the easy part belongs
When time’s up, the pad flips. The report opens by itself: how long the writer paused, a graph of the minutes, how long each sentence took, and a spreadsheet to keep. This is the useless hard part Eric set out to remove. His autoethnography assignment asks students to record a writing session, transcribe it, and note “even the moments of silence” (Howard, 2026a). Many of them, he says, don’t end up citing any data at all. The report does the recording and the counting for them.
I should say what I don’t know. Eric tells me no student has turned in the report’s numbers in a paper yet, so this is an account of what the tool does, not of what it has done for anyone.
It leaves the useful hard part alone, though. The report can say a writer stopped for twelve seconds after the third sentence. It can’t say why. The sheet asks students what their samples help them see about how they make meaning, and only the writer was there for those twelve seconds.
After isn’t automatically safe
My test has a limit, and I’ve already run into it in this column. In “The Line I’d Bold,” I gave a finished freewrite to an AI, and when the student had already picked a line, the AI talked them out of it every time. That happened after the writing, and it still took something from the writer. So the second half of the test needs a condition: afterward, a tool should hand over what happened, and leave what it means to the writer. The pad’s report does that. A chatbot asked for the best line doesn’t.
The test also doesn’t cover an AI that writes the first draft. That isn’t during or after. It’s instead, and Eric’s essay takes that case up on its own terms.
Next semester, when Eric asks his students which parts of learning to write have felt like “useless hard” and which like “useful hard” (Howard, 2026b), I’d give them one more column to fill in. Next to each hard thing, and each tool they’ve used to get around one, have them write when it happened: while the words were coming, or after they’d stopped. I suspect the answers will sort themselves faster than the argument would.
References
Bjork, E. L., & Bjork, R. A. (2011). Making things hard on yourself, but in a good way: Creating desirable difficulties to enhance learning. In M. A. Gernsbacher, R. W. Pew, L. M. Hough, & J. R. Pomerantz (Eds.), Psychology and the real world: Essays illustrating fundamental contributions to society (pp. 56–64). Worth Publishers.
Howard, E. S. (2026a). Autoethnography: A study of your own meaning-making practices [Assignment sheet]. https://ericshayhoward.com/teaching/assignments/autoethnography/
Howard, E. S. (2026b, November 16). Writing doesn’t have to be done the hard way. https://ericshayhoward.com/essays/not-the-hard-way/
Kluger, A. N., & DeNisi, A. (1996). The effects of feedback interventions on performance: A historical review, a meta-analysis, and a preliminary feedback intervention theory. Psychological Bulletin, 119(2), 254–284. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.119.2.254